purchase ecco Tagore disputes

tiandong12

As the Shanghai biennale,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], part of the "from buddhist paradise to middle-earth: seals social thought of dialogue," the day before yesterday ushered in India, a famous scholar palmer sand - it's auspicious, with "tagore, China and for nationalism's criticism" theme, wang hui, make a speech DaiJinHua, WangXiaoMing, ZhangRuLun, Chinese scholars such as NiWei according to it's doing live auspicious speech response. Although a scholarly dialogue and lasted for a whole day, but the Shanghai museum of the fourth floor lecture hall filled with young audience.
Check on special auspicious speech, he put the Chinese audience back to tagore trip to China in 1924, the China trip tagore by the Chinese cultural "encirclement and suppression", a very important reason is tagore's political thought. In addition to the great poet, tagore is also very important political India thinker, "he sure that Indus civilization has been playing very limited by national character for remarkable characteristics, by contrast, Indus civilization has been emphasized is community (i.e., what they call samaj). In England,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], before they reach India has been completed samaj from birth to satisfy the needs of the people of good work." Instead, tagore thinks,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], "European civilization sought by eliminating differences, or destroy differences, bring homogeneity to create unity." Obviously, against the western nation tagore and democratic political system. In 1924, tagore visited China restated his social and political views, tagore, "said in a speech in the east of some of us think we should copy and copy western. I can't believe it's right." It's really,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], "said fudge tagore indictment is that modern political organization forcibly carried out a set of too narrow and compulsory to contain human life complete range of disciplining the restriction and collective of request." Eager to west turn in the 1920s Chinese intellectuals, certainly can't agree to tagore's point of view, the critical moment of his rampant.
It's two hours to China with achish audience veiferate past, proposed the question is, eighty years ago, regardless of India and China, intellectuals to countries where to go forward different paths, the main argument centered in the western democratic politics, And tagore against the western political system including politics itself, but put back the traditional Indian community parts management. 80 years later, in tagore discussed problems still exist.
"Western does not provide the answer"
It's morning interviews with achish
"I have to do with the third world countries intellectuals come close"
Morning: you yesterday about tagore political thought speech, he spoke out from India internal not western national way, especially as he seeks to national rejects,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], this thought in modern India and controversy?
It's ji (hereinafter "check" under) : among intellectuals, about this issue is controversial. Some people think, modern state can only from the national transplant come in. But in fact, national only to satisfy the interests of the state and people part, which makes the nation and other countries involved compete, so there will be violence and war and national exploitation. Others believe that China and India strong, this kind of national risk will also happen. Herein lies the dispute. I last criticism nationalism, nationalism in India is very strong, political parties have to rely on it.
Morning: you I tend to be more from India internal seeking political governance resources?
Richard: I'm not saying modern management should from the traditional internal social structure to search, and because social governance can be modern, but at the same time does not conflict with the traditional social governance. I think, the modern social governance can have different from European nation-states form. We are not European country, whether India or China in politics have imagination.
Morning: actually Chinese intellectuals in understanding Chinese society, also often confused, exactly is to seek other explanation or internal resources.
Richard: to see other countries and social situation, of course, is very important, especially those with their own country similar area. This is why I am with the third world countries intellectuals relationship closer reasons. India,[link widoczny dla zalogowanych], China, South Africa, and the state-owned many similarities, will encounter similar difficulties, and strive to find solutions. Such an experience, everyone can share. For these developing countries, share, exchange ideas and experience is very important. When we turn to the west, instead will find, in their history can't find our present difficulties, they to the situation10 also is not interested, are we going to the 18th century, Europe in the 19th century history in search for our present the answer to the question? I on western historical experience very clearly, but they can provide experience and the answer doesn't convinces me, also does not completely suitable for us.
"They thought I didn't fully understand civil society concept"
Morning: generally, India is relatively successful transplant the western democratic political system of the country.
Richard: in Indian history many important people doesn't agree with India walk western-style road, Gandhi oneself to India into the western nation is hold a critic, he and his followers remained opposed the western political system. I don't think must first get transplant good western-style democracy again can do other things. Each country has its own unique way, we have our own experience, we form of democracy and governance affirmation and western different. Even India, although it for a long time for British colonial, but its democratic governance and British comparative without much similarities. We are facing in the modernization process of history and environment has completely different from western experience of 200 years ago, it has been completely different world.
Topics related articles：

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]

[link widoczny dla zalogowanych]